Karl Popper: Philosophy of Science, falsificationism

What is the difference between science and non-science? Austrian philosopher Karl Popper offers a very interesting criterion for this. To understand this criterion, it is necessary to first look at Popper's falsificationism.


Popper's falsificationism

Popper argued that scientific activity is basically an activity based on falsification, not verification. Verification means to prove that a proposition is 'right' based on some empirical evidence, while falsification means to judge a proposition to be 'wrong' based on some empirical evidence. However, Popper argued that hypotheses related to certain scientific laws could only be falsified, not tested. For example, let's say there is a lawful hypothesis that 'all swans are white'. So, is it possible to fully test this hypothesis in the true sense of the word? In practice, testing this hypothesis would require testing all swans. This may already seem very difficult, but let's say you've invested a lot of money and manpower to investigate all the swans on the planet. So, can this hypothesis be tested? Not like that. Because there may be swans that we have never discovered, there may be swans on other planets outside Earth, and there may have been a red swan in the past, but it may not exist now, so in the future there may be no white swans. In principle, it is impossible to check everything and verify everything perfectly because there are infinitely many cases where we have to test because the law is applied in this way. On the contrary, it is very easy to disprove. I just need to find one non-white swan. So, Popper proposes a model of scientific development that basically science develops sequentially by continuously disproving existing hypotheses, rather than developing by completely testing any one hypothesis. If there is a hypothesis A, then a superior hypothesis B appears to disprove the hypothesis, and a superior hypothesis C to disprove the hypothesis B appears and repeats the process of scientific development.


Falsification

In this way, Popper considered the role of falsification in science very essential, so he proposes the criterion of falsifiability as a criterion to distinguish science from non-science. For Popper, if a hypothesis is not empirically falsifiable, it is not a scientific hypothesis. For a scientific hypothesis, some empirical observation must be made to provide a criterion for disproving the hypothesis. For example, in the case of the hypothesis 'All swans are white' It was possible to clearly present the criteria for disproving it. However, in most cases, for example, philosophical or theological hypotheses are not empirically falsifiable. For example, with regard to the hypothesis of 'God is omnipotent', what kind of empirical observation can be made to disprove this hypothesis? As such, it may sound a little paradoxical, but in Popper's view, such knowledge asserted as some infallible and perfect truth is not scientific knowledge. Scientific knowledge, by its very nature, must be open to the possibility that it can be wrong. So, according to Popper, the core spirit of scientific rationality lies not in the dogmatic belief that 'I will discover the perfect truth through the advancement of science', but rather that 'my theory can be wrong at any time'. It is in such humble acknowledgment. Of course, those theories that have endured many falsifications over a long period of time are good theories, and it would be acceptable within scientific rationality to accept such a theory as a mainstream theory in science and have sufficient belief in it.


Objection to falsificationism

However, there is one very important objection to this Popper's falsificationism. The counterargument is, 'No, from that point of view, falsification is in principle impossible.' For example, say that a red swan has been found that disproves the hypothesis that 'all swans are white'. However, it is possible to argue about this. 'Because we have not yet developed the theory of the swan sufficiently, we have not yet found a way to distinguish the red swan from the real swans. It will be possible.' It is possible to claim this as much as possible. In fact, in the transition period when the existing Newtonian mechanics is being replaced by Einstein's theory of relativity, many scientists say, 'The observations that seem to disprove the Newtonian mechanics are only superficial in fact, and if we develop the existing Newtonian mechanics well, Without having to introduce the theory of relativity, I would be able to explain the disproved cases well'. Popper also partially acknowledges this objection.


Objection to objection

Nevertheless, Popper continued to maintain the position that 'falsification is logically far more powerful than verification', and Popper also argued that 'we should not cling to such complete and impeccable verifications or falsifications as to be desirable for science. You can't get a point of view." So, while the scientific community communicates and discusses with each other, it is possible to reasonably reasonably present the standards that a hypothesis is disproved by some empirical observation, but they say, 'Oh, that's not useless because it's not a complete falsification'. To say this is that we do not properly understand the nature of scientific rationality. Because the essence of scientific rationality lies in opening up the possibility of being wrong.


Wrap-up

Just because Popper presented the criteria for distinguishing science and non-science in this way, he in no way argued that only scientific knowledge was meaningful and non-scientific knowledge was meaningless. Even this analysis, which Popper performed on the nature of science, for example, is not, in itself, scientific knowledge. Because it is not empirically falsifiable. Nevertheless, we can obtain sufficiently intellectually meaningful reflections and lessons from this Popper's analysis. The moral core of Popper's falsificationism is that we need to be a little more open and humble about knowledge.

이 블로그의 인기 게시물

Characteristics of the right and left common to languages ​​around the world

I think therefore I am : Cogito Ergo Sum